01 · Scripture & Authority
Sola Scriptura: Why God's Word Has the Last Word
The church needs teachers, confessions, and tradition. Above all, it needs a standard by which its teachers and traditions can be examined.
Scripture · Church · Gospel
What sustains faith: God’s Word or a claim of ecclesiastical infallibility? Examine the arguments concerning Rome and Orthodoxy — thoroughly, with attention to sources, and from a clear Protestant position.
Explore the topics ↓Start with Sola Scriptura →35 articles · 102 sources and further resources · English
Start with the question of how doctrine is tested.
From ecclesiastical authority to the decisive dispute over the gospel.
Distinguish carefully between tradition, the veneration of images, and salvation.
Search for a topic, a Bible passage, or an objection. The search covers the full article text. “Both” means that the article is relevant to both conversations; the differences are identified in the text.
35 / 35
No matching articles. Try a shorter search term or reset the filters.
01 · Scripture & Authority
The church needs teachers, confessions, and tradition. Above all, it needs a standard by which its teachers and traditions can be examined.
02 · Scripture & Authority
That the apostles taught orally is undisputed. What is disputed is which later doctrines can legitimately appeal to that teaching.
03 · Scripture & Authority
The fallibility of a reader does not automatically make a text incomprehensible. The claim of an infallible magisterium must itself also be recognized and interpreted.
04 · Scripture & Authority
God is the foundation of true knowledge. This does not by itself establish an exclusive claim to infallibility for a particular church communion. Where is the missing step in the argument?
05 · Canon & Bible
God's Word receives its authority from God. How we recognize his books is an important, but separate, question.
06 · Canon & Bible
Neither a seamless early consensus nor a Catholic Bible invented only in 1546 stands up to scrutiny. The real story is more revealing.
07 · Canon & Bible
Orthodoxy possesses a broad common body of Scripture. Precisely for this reason, we must ask carefully what its different lists of books at the margins mean for an argument against Protestants.
08 · Canon & Bible
Canon, wording and translation are different questions. What the Septuagint, Jerome and Catholic teaching documents actually establish—and why God’s word remains the final standard.
09 · Church & History
An orderly succession of office is historically significant. However, apostolic truth is not guaranteed solely by the passing on of an office.
10 · Papacy
Peter occupies a prominent position in the New Testament. However, the path from this position to the universal jurisdiction of Roman successors consists of several additional claims.
11 · Papacy
Rome's early importance is undeniable. What needs to be examined historically is whether this importance already corresponded to the papal powers defined later.
12 · Church & History
Christian unity is a calling. Yet the truth of a doctrine is not determined by an unexamined number of denominations.
13 · Church & History
Christ preserves his Church. Does this promise also prove that his Church is fully realized only in one present-day communion and that its teaching authority can teach infallibly? The decisive biblical passages deserve close examination.
14 · Grace & Salvation
There is no salvation without Christ. But does that mean that only membership in a particular visible church saves? Roman Catholic and Orthodox sources require a more precise answer.
15 · Church & History
Nicaea deserves more than passing respect. Yet agreement with its teaching does not establish the infallibility of every subsequent ecclesiastical decision. Content, claim and demonstrable recognition are decisive.
16 · Church & History
The gospel claims to be true. Does this claim give churches the right to use state power against people of other beliefs? An examination of biblical limits and Catholic as well as Protestant sources.
17 · Grace & Salvation
Rome affirms the necessity of grace. The dispute concerns whether a person’s inwardly renewed condition forms part of justification and the acquisition of eternal life.
18 · Grace & Salvation
Christ bears our sin and defeats death. How do substitution, God’s justice and the unity of Father and Son fit together—and what do the early Christians actually attest?
19 · Grace & Salvation
James sharply criticizes an inactive faith. The question is, what salvation and what justification does he mean in this specific context?
20 · Grace & Salvation
Christ's promise sustains the believer's certainty. The serious consequences of disobedience are neither denied nor made into a second payment for salvation.
21 · Grace & Salvation
Participation in God’s life is a biblical concern. It does not yet answer the question of the basis on which a guilty person is justified and receives eternal life.
22 · Baptism & the Lord’s Supper
The Roman Mass is meant to sacramentally make present the same sacrifice of Christ. It must be examined whether the New Testament teaches this ongoing atoning offering.
23 · Baptism & the Lord’s Supper
The forceful language about Jesus’ flesh and blood demands explanation. It does not, without further steps, establish a doctrine of transubstantiation or the sacrifice of the Mass.
24 · Baptism & the Lord’s Supper
Baptism is a command of Christ, not a trivial addition. What is disputed is whether the act of water baptism necessarily conveys eternal life.
25 · Baptism & the Lord’s Supper
Christ gives his church real authority. This does not automatically imply the necessity of a complete private recitation of sins before a sacrificial priest.
26 · Grace & Salvation
Fasting and voluntary celibacy can honor God. But when does a spiritual exercise become a human law? Scripture helps distinguish self-control, ecclesiastical order and freedom of conscience.
27 · Mary & the Saints
The mother of Jesus deserves respect. Her biblical significance does not, however, automatically establish every later claim about sinlessness, assumption, and the mediation of salvation.
28 · Mary & the Saints
The fact that the departed live with Christ and may intercede for God’s people does not in itself establish a practice of prayer addressed to them.
29 · Images & Worship
The question is not merely whether Christians may make images. Nicaea II requires their religious veneration and attaches ecclesiastical condemnations to its rejection.
30 · Death & Final Perfection
The final holiness of the redeemed is not in dispute. What is disputed is a subsequent discharge of punishment and the Church’s authority to dispense acts of satisfaction.
31 · Orthodox Theology
God surpasses our understanding. It does not follow that we know nothing true about him, or that every later metaphysical explanation of his activity is binding.
32 · Orthodox Theology
“And from the Son” concerns the eternal relations within God. Linguistic differences, biblical statements, and the question of ecclesiastical authority must be examined separately.
33 · Church & History
Later formulations can clarify earlier truth. They can also add something to it. The difference must be demonstrated from their content.
34 · Church & History
A patristic quotation is only as strong as its text, its dating, and the claim that actually follows from it.
35 · Images & Worship
An extraordinary event must be examined. Even a genuine miracle does not automatically confirm every teaching of the religious community involved.
Scripture is our highest standard. The Church is called to hear, preserve, and proclaim the Word. Its teaching must be open to examination by that Word. This obligation also applies to Protestant teachers and confessions.
We affirm Free Grace: Eternal life is received through faith in the crucified and risen Christ. Discipleship, sanctification, God’s discipline, and reward must be taken seriously and distinguished from the basis of justification. Not every article describes a consensus of all Protestant traditions; differences are expressly identified.
First clarify the specific claim. Read the strongest argument for the opposing position. Examine the biblical texts and linked sources in context. Answer the objection, then ask about the standard that should also apply to your conversation partner. Arguments should be incisive; personal contempt contributes nothing to truth.
These texts address the central areas of dispute as a connected introduction to further study. They do not replace a complete history of every controversy. Where an interpretation is disputed or historical evidence supports only a limited conclusion, that limit is identified.
Sources, editions, and method →