Distinguishing truth, authority and infallibility
“You confess Christ’s deity with Nicaea; therefore, you must also recognize the infallible authority of our Church.” This objection touches on something important: Christians do not receive their faith without a history. Congregations, teachers and confessions have publicly preserved it and defended it against errors. Nevertheless, the truth of a particular decision does not, without further justification, entail the guaranteed freedom from error of a comprehensive ecclesiastical decision-making procedure.
Three questions must be kept separate: Is the statement true? Was the assembly authorized to make a binding decision? Was it protected from error under certain conditions in doing so? An answer can be true without having been reached infallibly. A legitimate authority can require obedience without being free from error in every statement. And even a justified claim to infallibility must make clear which statements it covers. These distinctions are no Protestant evasion; their first purpose is to prevent different claims from being conflated.
What Rome actually claims
Lumen gentium states that a council is ecumenical only if Peter’s successor confirms it or at least accepts it as such. At the same time, the document distinguishes individual bishops from the college of bishops teaching together with the pope. Infallibility is also ascribed to the college dispersed throughout the world and united in communion when its members agree in presenting a doctrine of faith or morals as something to be held definitively. The Roman model is thus limited neither to conciliar assemblies nor to definitions issued by the pope alone. [1]
Canon law additionally requires that an infallible definition be manifestly established. Alongside this, it recognizes religious submission to authentic teaching that is not proposed as a definitive definition. The inference “Not infallible means wholly nonbinding within the Catholic order” is therefore mistaken. It would be equally mistaken to declare every word of conciliar minutes, every disciplinary provision and every theological rationale an infallible definition of faith without distinction. [2]
The Protestant question addresses the stronger claim: What revelation grounds this particular guarantee, and how do we recognize that it actually applies to the decision being cited? Merely restating the ecclesiastical rule explains the claim but does not yet establish its divine institution.
What a local synod on the canon can accomplish
This distinction is particularly important for early lists of biblical books. A regional synod is not an ecumenical council merely because its canonical list has survived. Yet it follows neither that its list is false nor that it can have no evidential value. It may be a substantial witness to actual recognition. Within the Catholic model, one must also examine whether the teaching in question was authoritatively proposed elsewhere through the ordinary and universal magisterium. [3]
Anyone claiming an infallible decision on the canon must therefore establish more than a place name and a date. Anyone disputing it should, for their part, avoid claiming that no reliable knowledge of the books existed at all before a later solemn definition. Inspiration, recognizability, ecclesiastical use and dogmatic definition remain different questions.
The Orthodox answer: recognition by the whole Church
The OCA’s Orthodox self-presentation expressly makes clear that not every large assembly of bishops was automatically accepted. It connects the seven ecumenical councils with the assent of the entire Church and also mentions local synods whose decisions likewise received general recognition. Mere exclusion from the traditional count of seven therefore does not necessarily mean dogmatic insignificance. [4]
The joint Orthodox–Catholic Chieti document describes the development of criteria of recognition during the first millennium. For Nicaea II, it mentions, among other things, the agreement of ecclesiastical heads, Rome’s participation and conformity with earlier councils. Reception by the whole Church appears as a decisive criterion of ecumenicity. This is a theological dialogue document, not a new infallible conciliar definition. [5]
Reception in this context does not simply mean a vote by which an initially false doctrine subsequently becomes true. It means Spirit-guided recognition of apostolic teaching that is already true. Protestant criticism must address this stronger understanding.
The question reception still needs to answer
If the whole Church recognizes a council, it must be explained how this whole becomes identifiable in a dispute. Whose assent counts? What period is decisive? How are minorities with sound reasons distinguished from false teachers? Mathematical unanimity among every baptized person is not a fair requirement here. But appealing to the Spirit’s work does not replace every explanation of how a particular historical judgment can be examined either.
The justification becomes particularly difficult if “the true Church” designates exclusively those who recognize the council in question, while the council’s truth is derived solely from its recognition by “the true Church.” Two still-disputed claims then merely ground each other. A broader argument from apostolic teaching, ecclesial communion and a substantiated account of history is not thereby refuted. It must, however, actually be presented. The legitimate question in response is not “Why is there history at all?” It is “What reasons distinguish correct recognition from a selection made to fit retrospectively?”
Jerusalem 1672: more than a nonbinding private opinion
The Confession of Dositheus attributes no less authority to the Church’s testimony than to Scripture, because the same Spirit teaches both. Decree XII connects Spirit-guided teaching with fathers and teachers and identifies the ecumenical synods as their standard. This text makes a real ecclesiastical truth claim; when its doctrinal statements become inconvenient, it should not simply be treated as a private aside. [6]
These statements do not, however, entail that any arbitrary synod is infallible regardless of its content and recognition. The precise status of a later assembly requires separate evidence of its reception. “Not one of the seven councils” and “without a binding doctrinal claim” are no more synonymous than “some synod” and “the infallible mouthpiece of the entire Church.”
May a Protestant confess Nicaea?
Yes. The Nicene Creed declares the Son truly divine, begotten and not made, of one essence with the Father. [7] Assent to this may rest on the conviction that these statements reliably express the meaning of Scripture. John 1:1–3 distinguishes the Word from everything that came into being and confesses his deity; Hebrews 1:1–12 unfolds the Son’s unique position. The creed helps protect these statements against an interpretation that places Christ among created beings.
Athanasius explains why the bishops employed more precise terms: general biblical expressions were being reinterpreted in ways that also applied to creatures. The more exact wording was therefore intended to safeguard Scripture’s meaning. This does not prove that Athanasius held a complete modern Protestant model of authority. But it does show that his defense of the council also argues substantively from Scripture. [8]
The objection of arbitrariness remains serious: a Protestant may not simply retain whatever they like. Agreement and disagreement must be justified from the same binding revelation. The Westminster Confession requires reverent acceptance of scriptural synodal decisions while also holding later councils to be fallible. This concerns a ministerial, limited authority, not the abolition of shared teaching. [9]
History demands more than the label “council”
In the letter to the African bishops, Athanasius and his fellow signatories defend Nicaea against an appeal to Ariminum. They discuss the proceedings, pressure, changing formulas and doctrinal content. At the same time, they assign Nicaea itself the highest binding authority. The text is thus neither a neutral overall account nor a general attack on councils. Yet it demonstrates that even then, merely appealing to an assembly did not end every examination. [10]
Chalcedon’s Definition of Faith, in turn, confirms Nicaea and the teaching of the 150 fathers of Constantinople and explains its own Christology as preserving the faith handed down. [11] Earlier recognition, later reaffirmation and substantive explanation work together. This history entails neither any present-day confessional model as a whole nor the loss of value of all conciliar decisions.
The standard remains God’s revelation
The Protestant position defended here begins with God’s self-authenticating word. Historical research does not generate its authority and is itself fallible. It can examine claims about tradition, clarify concepts and show what a particular assembly actually said. One’s own interpretation also remains accountable; appealing to Scripture does not authorize ignoring counterarguments.
Acts 15 shows joint deliberation under apostolic leadership and a binding decision. A general guarantee against error for all later forms of ecclesiastical decision-making still requires justification from this. Conversely, the fallibility of later teachers refutes neither the truth of apostolic testimony nor every legitimate ecclesiastical order.
The decisive question in response is therefore: What specific statement am I to believe, on the basis of what divine promise is the decision regarded as infallible, and how is this particular decision recognized as bearing the promised authority? Anyone making these three steps explicit is conducting a theological debate open to examination. The statement “The Church has decided” alone does not settle it in advance.
Sources & Evidence
The numbers in the text point to the specific passages cited. Most linked editions are in English. This article is a translation of the German study.
- Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (1964) — Nos. 22 and 25. Official Roman Catholic primary source; No. 22 on papal confirmation of ecumenical councils, No. 25 on the ordinary and universal magisterium and infallible definitions. Nos. 20–27 examined in context.↩ Back to passage
- Code of Canon Law, can. 747–755: The Teaching Function of the Church — can. 749 §3; 752–753. Official Roman Catholic primary source; especially can. 749–753. Infallibility, definitive teaching and religious submission must be distinguished; not every binding instruction is an infallible definition.↩ Back to passage
- Code of Canon Law, can. 747–755: The Teaching Function of the Church — can. 749 §2 and 750 §1. Official Roman Catholic primary source; especially can. 749–753. Infallibility, definitive teaching and religious submission must be distinguished; not every binding instruction is an infallible definition.↩ Back to passage
- Orthodox Church in America: The Councils — Section “The Councils”. Orthodox ecclesiastical self-presentation of councils, recognition by the whole Church and local synods that were also received. Not an independent pan-Orthodox dogmatic definition; its authority as a source must not be overstated.↩ Back to passage
- Orthodox–Catholic Dialogue Commission: Chieti Document (2016) — No. 18. Joint theological dialogue document, especially No. 18, pages 5–6, on the development of criteria of recognition and reception by the whole Church. Neither a new ecumenical council nor an independently infallible definition. Official PDF reproduction by the Archdiocese of Chieti-Vasto.↩ Back to passage
- Confession of Dositheus / Synod of Jerusalem (1672) — Decrees II and XII. Orthodox confession; English translation by J. N. W. B. Robertson, 1899; its historical reception must be considered separately↩ Back to passage
- First Council of Nicaea (325) — Creed. Conciliar source; English translation at New Advent↩ Back to passage
- Athanasius, De decretis: Defense of the Nicene Terms — §§18–20. Primary text in English translation; §§18–20 explain the council’s more precise terms from the meaning of Scripture. The high authority Athanasius himself assigns to the council must still be taken into account.↩ Back to passage
- Westminster Confession of Faith — Chapter XXXI.2–3, OPC version. Reformation confession; text hosted by the Orthodox Presbyterian Church↩ Back to passage
- Athanasius and the Egyptian Bishops, Letter to the Bishops of Africa — §§1–4. Primary text in English translation; §§1–4 defend Nicaea against an appeal to Ariminum. A partisan contemporary account: neither a neutral overall presentation nor a blanket proof against every council.↩ Back to passage
- Council of Chalcedon (451): Extracts from the Acts and Definition of Faith — Definition of Faith, fifth session. Primary texts in English translation; Definition of Faith from the fifth session, confirmation of Nicaea and Constantinople, and confession of the one Christ in two natures. Editorial commentary must be distinguished from the council’s wording.↩ Back to passage