The canon argument in its strongest form
The objection is this: The Bible does not contain an inspired, comprehensive table of contents. A Protestant must therefore use extra-biblical tradition to compile their Bible. If this tradition is fallible, then their canon remains uncertain. An infallible Bible can only be reliably identified by an infallible church.
The first sentence identifies a real problem of knowledge. However, it does not imply the existence of a specific infallible church office. There is no necessary connection between the existence of a certain truth and the infallibility of every human path to knowledge. A fallible person can recognize true statements without thereby becoming infallible in all their judgments. Otherwise, no one could recognize which church is infallible before they themselves had already become infallible.
Three questions that need to be separated
What makes a book the Word of God? Its inspiration by God. How is it recognized? Through God's self-testimony in his Word, the work of his Spirit, and the corresponding testimonies of its apostolic origin and ecclesial reception. When is a list established as binding? That is a question of church history. A book can long be the Word of God and effective as such before a later assembly includes it in a list.
This distinction prevents two errors. The Church does not retrospectively generate inspiration. But its work of transmission is not meaningless either. A process of reception is different from a process of creation. In his work on the canon, Michael Kruger emphasizes precisely this distinction between the authority of books and their historical recognition. [1]
The solid core and the blurrier edges
This model allows for varying degrees of certainty regarding recognizability without inventing different levels of divine inspiration. If a book is inspired, it is not merely seventy percent God’s Word. Our knowledge of it may still be better or worse grounded. The quality of the book and the certainty of our judgment are two different things.
The doctrinal starting point is the firm core of the New Testament, especially its clear didactic statements. Narrative texts belong to this core and must be interpreted as such. In addition, there is the Old Testament, confirmed by the New Testament, the generally transmitted body of Jewish writings, and finally the less clearly identifiable peripheral areas including apocryphal historical books and supplements. This order describes relationships of knowledge and interpretation, not different degrees of inspiration.
The practical consequence is essential: An uncertain marginal text must not overturn a firmly established doctrine, nor should it alone bear the weight of a new, far-reaching obligation of faith. One can profitably read a historical text without simply granting it the authority to redefine the Gospel. Likewise, one should not spontaneously relegate an inconvenient book of the recognized canon to the margins simply because its interpretation is difficult.
Self-authentication is more than self-assertion
The starting point is God's truthful word. It does not derive its ultimate authority from a higher human judgment. If another standard were to definitively decide whether God is credible, that standard would be the highest authority. However, this does not mean that every scripture becomes true simply by virtue of its own claim. Conflicting claims of revelation must be examined in terms of their content, their premises, and their relationship to the already recognized word.
Self-authentication is therefore not a license for the feeling: “This book touches me, so it must be inspired.” The Spirit does not lead to arbitrary private lists independent of the content of the Word. Apostolic origin, agreement with the context of revelation, and widespread early acceptance all possess testimonial value. They are not placed as a higher tribunal above God, but are understood as interconnected indications of the identity of His Word.
The Westminster Confession accordingly distinguishes the witness of the Church and the qualities of Scripture from the ultimate assurance through the Spirit. This should not be interpreted as a devaluation of scholarship, nor as an assertion that any sincere reader can reconstruct a canon list from scratch without historical knowledge. [2]
Hebrews or Tobit: The question remains concrete
An opponent may rightly ask why one controversial book is included while another is omitted. The answer must then focus on the specific book: its early attestation, apostolic context, relationships within the Bible, usage, and reception history. Not every book was universally accepted at the same time. The Epistle to the Hebrews does not become irrelevant simply because its authorship is debated. Conversely, spiritually impressive content alone is not sufficient proof of apostolic origin.
The model therefore does not claim an unbroken historical chain of evidence that provides every detail with the same certainty. It denies that every marginal uncertainty invalidates the entire body of revelation. Anyone who makes complete certainty about every marginal book the condition of all theological knowledge must explain how Christians could have any authoritative belief and teaching before later comprehensive lists.
The same standard for church infallibility
The Catholic interlocutor identifies his Church through texts, historical testimonies, and interpretation. He must recognize which councils are legitimate, which definitions are infallible, and how they are to be understood. A subsequent appeal to an infallible body does not negate this initial task of understanding. This is not a refutation of every conceivable ecclesiastical infallibility, but rather a refutation of the purported simple solution to all human fallibility.
Even Orthodox voices recognize a firm center and less sharply defined Old Testament boundaries. The Orthodox priest John Whiteford explains precisely this distinction. His model of tradition is not the scriptural model presented here; however, his explanation shows that different degrees of certainty in our knowledge does not necessarily mean the end of binding doctrine. [3]
The crucial follow-up question
Why should a fallible person be able to reliably recognize the true, infallible Church, but not, in principle, be able to reliably recognize the Scripture attested to by that Church? Anyone who makes different demands here must explain the difference. The assertion of an infallible Magisterium must not be introduced as an unearned premise into an argument that is supposed to prove precisely that Magisterium.
Sources & Evidence
The numbers in the text point to the specific passages cited. Most linked editions are in English. This article is a translation of the German study.
- Michael J. Kruger: Is Tradition the Only Way to Know Which Books Are in the Canon? — Discussion of the relationship between canon and tradition. Protestant secondary source on recognizing the canon↩ Back to passage
- Westminster Confession of Faith — 1.4–5. Reformation confession; text hosted by the Orthodox Presbyterian Church↩ Back to passage
- John Whiteford: The Orthodox Canon — Introduction and Conclusion on Certainty Regarding Individual Books. An Orthodox apologetic article by a priest; not a definition binding on the whole Church↩ Back to passage