Skip to content

Baptism & the Lord’s Supper

Confession, the Power of the Keys, and Access to God

Christ gives his church real authority. This does not automatically imply the necessity of a complete private recitation of sins before a sacrificial priest.

CHRISTOlogisch · 4-minute read · Sources as of November 16, 2026

In this article
  1. What John 20 really says
  2. The Roman rationale
  3. The apostolic practice as an aid to interpretation
  4. Confessing sins to one another
  5. Protestant confession is not a contradiction
  6. The follow-up question
  7. Sources & Evidence

What John 20 really says

The risen Christ sends his disciples, promises the Spirit, and connects their mission with the forgiveness and retention of sins (John 20:21–23). It would be wrong to reduce this to a consequence-free religious expression of opinion. The apostolic proclamation of the gospel is God's authorized message; its acceptance or rejection has real consequences.

The point of contention is what specific form this authority takes. Must every serious transgression committed after baptism be individually reported to an ordained priest so that he can judicially pronounce absolution? Or do the apostles and the congregation they instruct exercise this authority through the authoritative proclamation of the promise of forgiveness and through congregational discipline? The text must substantiate this further specification.

The Roman rationale

Trent derives a judicial authority for priests from the power of the keys. Because a judge must know the case, the individual confession of all mortal sins recalled after careful examination is necessary. This is an argumentative conclusion, not simply a repetition of John 20. It is precisely this conclusion that must be examined. [1]

The authority to pronounce God's judgment on faith and unbelief does not automatically imply an obligatory procedure for the complete assessment of all individual transgressions. For this to be the case, it would first have to be proven that John 20 specifically refers to such an individual court of punishment and absolution. The judicial analogy must not presuppose the contested definition itself.

The apostolic practice as an aid to interpretation

In Acts 10:43, Peter proclaims forgiveness through Christ's name to every believer. In Acts 13:38–39, Paul proclaims forgiveness and justification through Christ for the believer. Both texts present a genuine, binding promise of salvation. They do not require a prior, complete individual confession to the apostle.

Matthew 18:15–20 connects binding and loosing with the handling of specific guilt within the church. 1 Corinthians 5 and 2 Corinthians 2:5–11 show excommunication and readmission. The church thus exercises serious responsibility, without every one of these passages describing a sacramental private tribunal. This is a positive biblical context of ecclesiastical authority, not an abolition of authority.

Confessing sins to one another

James 5:16 calls for mutual confession of sins and intercessory prayer. In the preceding context, elders are called to the sick. This implies an important pastoral ministry, but the wording explicitly shifts to mutual confession. An exclusive monopoly of confession by a priestly class cannot simply be equated with this verse.

1 John 1:9 links forgiveness and purification to confessing one's sins before the faithful and righteous God. The context is light, truth, and fellowship. The text does not encourage concealment from those affected. However, it does not mention an ordained mediator as an indispensable additional requirement for accessing God's forgiveness.

Protestant confession is not a contradiction

The Reformation did not completely abolish personal confession of sins and pastoral absolution. The Augsburg Confession explicitly retains private absolution but rejects the requirement to list all sins. Anyone who considers every absolution offered by a pastor to be Roman Catholic is unaware of this distinction. [2]

The crucial line lies between a minister who points to Christ's reliable promise and a system that ties access to forgiveness to an additional, necessary procedure not demonstrated by the text. Spiritual help can be liberating. It must not bind conscience with conditions that Christ did not set.

The follow-up question

Where do the apostles themselves stipulate that every Christian must confess all remembered serious sins individually to an ordained priest? And how is this requirement to be reconciled with their immediate promises of forgiveness to believers? The assertion of an authority does not yet answer the question of its precise scope and exercise.

Sources & Evidence

The numbers in the text point to the specific passages cited. Most linked editions are in English. This article is a translation of the German study.

  1. Council of Trent, Session XIV (1551) — Session XIV, Chapter 5. Doctrine and canons on penance and confession↩ Back to passage
  2. Augsburg Confession (1530) — Articles XI and XXV. Lutheran confession; English edition on Book of Concord↩ Back to passage
All sources and notes on method

German original