In plain language
Here we ask what teaching about God means for faith, prayer and daily life. Distinguish what the Bible says, what a person already understands and what that person actually rejects.
You can open explanations of terms within the text. The detailed reasoning and sources follow below.
The objection
One God as one person is easier to imagine than one God in three persons. If a simpler explanation is possible, it should be preferred to a complicated doctrine of the Trinity.
Terms explained: Trinity
- Trinity
- There is one God. The Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit are distinct from one another, and each is truly God. This means neither three gods nor three roles played by one person.
1. Brevity is no independent criterion of truth
An explanation can become shorter by omitting some facts it is meant to explain. This gains nothing. The Unitarian formula, like the Trinitarian one, must explain why the Word is called God, why the Son possessed glory with the Father before the world, and why the same honor belongs to him as to the Father.
Terms explained: Trinity, Unitarianism, Revelation
- Trinity
- There is one God. The Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit are distinct from one another, and each is truly God. This means neither three gods nor three roles played by one person.
- Unitarianism
- Views holding that God is only one person. Their advocates differ in what they say about Jesus, so their actual position needs to be established first.
- Revelation
- God makes something known that we would not simply know by ourselves. The Bible is understood here as God's communication. “The Revelation of John” also names the last book of the New Testament.
The actual comparison is therefore not “one sentence against a longer sentence” but: Which interpretation holds revelation's statements together without continually reconstructing their meaning? A simple formula with many retrospective exceptions may be the more elaborate explanation overall.
2. The supposedly simple starting point is already a decision
“God is one person” seems self-evident only if every unity is understood on the pattern of a created single individual. This assumption is not neutral. Before listening to God's Word, it determines what personal reality God may possess.
We, by contrast, begin with God's self-revelation. His Word is no uncertain object before an independent human tribunal. It is the criterion through which we rightly situate God and our own knowledge. This does not release us from thinking; it obliges us to understand the received statements precisely and consistently.
Terms explained: God's self-revelation, Revelation
- God's self-revelation
- God makes himself known. In the view presented here, humans do not first have to work out who God is by themselves; they can hear what he says about himself in the Bible.
- Revelation
- God makes something known that we would not simply know by ourselves. The Bible is understood here as God's communication. “The Revelation of John” also names the last book of the New Testament.
3. Unity and diversity are original in God
John 17,24 attests love between Father and Son before creation. God did not have to create the world to have a real relationship of love for the first time. His perfection does not depend on a created counterpart.
Poythress shows that unity and diversity in the created world reflect God's own fullness at their creaturely level. No limited human perspective is the ultimate criterion; this lies in God's perfect knowledge.[1] One cannot calculate the number three from this without revelation. But it shows why God's personal fullness is no retrospectively imposed problem.
Terms explained: Revelation
- Revelation
- God makes something known that we would not simply know by ourselves. The Bible is understood here as God's communication. “The Revelation of John” also names the last book of the New Testament.
4. “Simplicity” also has a precise theological meaning
In classical doctrine, divine simplicity means that God is not composite or dependent on constituents. It does not mean that every human can easily survey him.[2] Anyone confusing the two makes the limits of their imagination the measure of divine reality.
Terms explained: Divine simplicity, Trinity
- Divine simplicity
- “Simple” here does not mean easy to understand. It means that God is not made of parts and needs nothing added in order to be God.
- Trinity
- There is one God. The Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit are distinct from one another, and each is truly God. This means neither three gods nor three roles played by one person.
The Trinity is therefore not true because of its difficulty. It is true because God reveals himself as Father, Son and Spirit. Its intellectual demands arise because none of these statements may be sacrificed. Christian thought seeks the clearest presentation of this truth, not the God most conveniently reduced to a familiar human pattern.
Biblical texts in context
Sources and further study
- Vern S. Poythress, Making Sense of the WorldCh. 1, pp. 10–12: Trinitarian unity and diversity; God's knowledge as criterion.
- James E. Dolezal, God without PartsCh. 2: simplicity as noncomposition, not easy imaginability.